I tried America.gov, and I'm wary of trusting it with my data

Date:
Wed, 30 Sep 2026 15:54:37 +0000

Description:
I tried the new AI-powered America.gov and found a useful government guide whose ambitious plans raise much bigger questions about privacy, security and trust

FULL STORY ======================================================================Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Reddit Pinterest Flipboard Threads Email Share this article 0 Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google Newsletter Subscribe to our newsletter America.gov has a pitch that I suspect almost anyone who has dealt with the federal government will understand immediately. Instead of figuring out which department, or obscure corner of an agency, controls the thing you need, you tell one website what you are trying to accomplish. Then AI sorts out the bureaucracy for you.

The Trump administration launched the AI-powered America.gov this week as a single digital front door for federal services. Its ambitions eventually extend to passports, Medicare, Social Security, and government jobs, but the version available today starts with something much more familiar. There is a big conversational box where you can ask the government a question in
ordinary language. There is familiar technology behind it too. Google Gemini and Grok are being used. The system draws on information scattered across thousands of government websites and attempts to turn it into a useful answer with links back to official sources. Latest Videos From TechRadar Watch full video here:

I spent some time trying it, and I can see the appeal. I am considerably less convinced that I am ready for what the government wants to build on top of
it. No learning curve Seoul City at night, South Korea. (Image credit: Social Security Administration) America.gov doesn't require much instruction. You type what you need in the same conversational style you would use with ChatGPT, Gemini, or Grok and let the site work out which pieces of government information are relevant. For anyone accustomed to AI chatbots, there is essentially no learning curve. You may like Metas new AI agent demands
serious trust OpenAI tries to build a persona that makes it our equal, and yes, now even I'm very worried Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei says people think governments are using AI to screw them over, and thats why the tech is having a a crisis of trust and hes exactly right

I started with the suggestion by the chatbot to ask how to replace a Social Security card. America.gov explained the basic process and directed me toward the appropriate government resources. I knew beforehand that my journey
should begin with the Social Security Administration, but it was still
helpful information.

I tried the same approach with passports and Medicare. Again, being able to describe the outcome I wanted was easier than figuring out the vocabulary
used by the relevant agency. Tell America.gov what you are trying to accomplish rather than throwing a few keywords into the box and you'll probably be okay. Get daily insight, inspiration and deals in your inbox Sign up for breaking news, reviews, opinion, top tech deals, and more. Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

That said it's important to click the sources and not just take it on faith. America.gov can synthesize information, but generative AI adds another interpretive layer between you and the underlying government material. If I
am checking a deadline or eligibility requirement, I would verify the important details on the agency page before acting on them. A hallucinated fact is annoying when an AI is helping plan dinner and considerably more consequential when it involves healthcare.

The site's first day also provided an unusually vivid example of why I don't want to treat its answers as immutable government truth. In my tests, the chatbot didn't provide any political information when I asked it questions, which is what the website originally promised.

According to an AP report , America.gov initially answered questions about subjects including who won the 2020 election, presidential term limits, and climate change using information from government sources. Then some of the answers changed. That isn't evidence of a security problem, but it raises questions of who decides what a government AI service chatbot is allowed to say. If America.gov is going to become a primary interface between Americans and their government, changes to its behavior should not disappear invisibly behind a chat box. What to read next I tried Proton's AI Paper Trail tool
and I couldn't believe how much data chatbots know about me 'The
chicification of surveillance is deeply concerning' why our tech is getting far too close (and what you can do about it) South Koreas free AI experiment could become a global blueprint Gov AI privacy The current chatbot is only
the first stage. The White House says America.gov will eventually allow
people to complete government transactions rather than merely tell them where to go. The executive order also calls for Login.gov integration so people can authenticate themselves and access participating services through the same portal.

Passport services and Medicare enrollment are planned for the next couple of years, as are legal name changes and federal job applications. The broader idea is that government systems should stop repeatedly asking people for information another part of the government already possesses. If implemented well, that could remove some genuinely miserable bureaucracy. But those are also the features that make me nervous.

Right now, I can use America.gov without giving it much of anything. Asking how passport renewal works is basically an information request. The promised version could sit between my authenticated identity and some of the most sensitive interactions I have with the federal government. That requires an enormous amount of trust.

The executive order creating America.gov says agencies should retain custody and control of their own records, that the system should avoid creating a centralized federal record on Americans, and that personal information should be protected.

Those are good promises. Recent history gives me reasons to want considerably more than promises. The Government Accountability Office examined access
given to a Department of Government Efficiency team working with Treasury's Bureau of the Fiscal Service in 2025 and found that one DOGE employee had access to three federal payment systems and could view, copy and print data. Investigators also found that Treasury had issued the employee a laptop without first ensuring that the employee had agreed to follow security rules intended to prevent data from being transmitted outside the bureau.

And, in March, GAO reported that federal agencies do not always have the technology and resources needed to ensure privacy protections when using AI. Its panel of experts warned that AI can expose personal information contained in underlying datasets, while GAO concluded that existing government-wide guidance did not fully address the major privacy challenges it identified. That report landed only six months before the government launched an AI service it intends to expand across some of its largest public-facing programs.

None of this means Gemini or Grok is quietly reading my Social Security
record when I ask America.gov a question. It does mean I want answers before America.gov evolves from helpful government concierge into authenticated government middleman.

The administration is asking Americans to eventually trust America.gov. Given the documented problems around government data access and the GAO's warning that federal AI privacy guidance remains incomplete, that trust should be earned technically rather than requested rhetorically. Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. The best business laptops for all budgets Our top picks, based on real-world testing and comparisons

Read our full guide to the best business laptops 1. Best overall: Dell 14 Premium 2. Best on a budget: Acer Aspire 5 3. Best MacBook: Apple MacBook Pro 14-inch (M4)



======================================================================
Link to news story: https://www.techradar.com/ai-platforms-assistants/i-tried-america-gov-and-the- ai-chatbot-isnt-the-part-im-worried-about


--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A49 (Linux/64)
* Origin: tqwNet Technology News (1337:1/100)